Deutsche Vermeidung von Entscheidung
In Düsseldorf on 29 September 2025 Chancellor Friedrich Merz said: “We are not at war, but nor are we at peace any more.” In the first nine months of 2026 the UN counted more civilians killed and injured in Ukraine than in the whole of 2025. DURCHD8’s study of January 2026 reads that state between war and peace as a way of deciding. Thresholds stay open, mandates stretch, responsibility spreads, and the open decision still acts, on people far from where it was left open.
Companion Documents
Essay — A readable analytical article framing the subject, context, and significance.
Briefing — The decision-maker’s version: key findings, implications, and operational relevance.
Assessment — A concentrated analytical diagnosis for readers who need the argument.
Architectural Analysis — The complete scientific analysis.
Current State
As of 18 October 2026. The pressure the study described has grown, and the language it named has outlasted a year of attacks. In the night of 4 August a drone carrying explosives was found at Leipzig/Halle airport, near a Ukrainian cargo aircraft. Its charge failed to go off. On 1 September the government traced it to people acting for Russian state agencies and closed the Russian consulate general in Bonn. “We are not at war, but we are the daily target of hybrid warfare,” interior minister Alexander Dobrindt said. NATO's Ankara declaration of July names hybrid threats once and sets no threshold.
In Ukraine the UN counted 328 civilians killed and 2,105 injured in September, 85 per cent more than a year earlier, and called the first two weeks of October among the deadliest for civilians in years. On 21 August two drones struck a full shopping centre in Kryvyi Rih, half an hour apart, and killed at least 13 people. Talks on ending the war stalled in early October, and the EU's 22nd package of sanctions has yet to be agreed. The UN's count for October is the next marker.
Mechanism
The study draws two rooms. In the first, in Berlin and in Brussels, decisions are taken or left open. In the second the costs arrive, in destroyed civilian infrastructure and in lives. In strategic interaction, the study holds, there is no neutral state. A decision left open is noticed, a finding left unmade is interpreted, a classification withheld is factored in. Held for long enough, such a mode shifts what partners and adversaries expect and makes reactions predictable because they fail to come. Time then works for whoever counts on its effect.
The pattern has addresses in Germany. In December 2025 the federal government and the states opened a joint centre against drones, which pools their expertise and situational pictures around the clock. The decision-making powers of each authority, the government writes, remain unaffected. A drone that cannot be attributed beyond doubt to a foreign state is a matter for the police of the state it flies over, the federal police take charge over railways and airports, and the Bundeswehr may help in support. The rules follow the federal order. In the study’s words for the result, responsibilities are spread, with the decision bundled nowhere.
Responsibility, it concludes, arises from foreseeable effect as well as from intent.
At Stake
The study counts the price where decisions stay open, in destroyed civilian infrastructure, in weakened communities and in lives. In Ukraine that price now falls on the places of daily life. In August the UN recorded 32 attacks on the depots and shops of six large food and retail companies, against 11 in July, and the head of its monitoring mission spoke of strikes on “the infrastructure of everyday civilian life”. While Germany's thresholds stay undefined, others use the room they leave. The study ends with the people who pay: “Civilians. Soldiers. People. Not part of the decision. But bearers of the consequences. With everything they have.”
At which point does keeping a question open cost more than answering it, and who in the alliance would say so first?
Political Relations
Every decision the study examines needs several hands. In Berlin the government attributes attacks and answers them, while the Bundestag sets what the armed forces may do at home. On 26 February it allowed the Bundeswehr to shoot down drones as a last resort, in support of the states and their police, with the votes of the CDU/CSU, the AfD and the SPD against the Greens and Die Linke. Since June 2025 Berlin has kept the details of its military aid to Ukraine confidential.
In NATO every step needs consensus. The alliance counts nine requests for consultations under Article 4 since 1949, the last by Estonia in September 2025. In the EU sanctions need the consent of all twenty-seven governments. Washington leads the talks on the war. On 8 October its secretary of state called a negotiated end currently unattainable, and Moscow said no talks in that format were planned. Ukraine sits outside every one of these rooms and carries the costs the study describes.
Research
DURCHD8 published Vermeidung von Entscheidung unter Druck on 27 January 2026, a short German text in eight steps. It starts from a mode of deciding that can be observed in NATO, the EU and Germany, follows its effects on partners and adversaries, the role of time and the costs that leave the room where decisions are taken, and ends at the point of irreversibility, where losses are beyond repair. It leaves motives and guilt aside and sets itself no date. Its claim is testable by the effects it describes: burdens moving to allies, to the future and to people outside the decision.
Three other studies carry the question further. Hybrid Warfare Is Already Working, published a month before, had found decision integrity in parts of Europe already degraded under hybrid pressure. NATO Consensus as Ceremony found the decisions of spring 2026 taken away from the alliance’s council table. Zeitenende: Macht ohne Bedeutung ist bedeutungslos follows the party system beneath Germany’s government.
The study marks the moment at which inaction stops being neutral. The first threshold that Berlin, Brussels or the alliance writes down will show whether that moment has been recognised.

